Old City Barbeque Menu

The Old City Barbeque Menu offers a mouthwatering selection of dishes perfect for those craving rich, smoky flavors. Located in the heart of Williamsburg, VA, this spot has earned a reputation for serving up some of the finest barbeque in the area. From tender, slow-cooked ribs to juicy pulled pork sandwiches, every item is prepared with care and the finest ingredients. The menu features a variety of classic barbeque sides, including creamy coleslaw, tangy baked beans, and crispy fries, all designed to complement the hearty main dishes. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch or a leisurely dinner, there’s something on the menu to satisfy every craving. Enjoy a laid-back atmosphere with flavorful food that hits all the right notes for a delicious meal.

FAMILY MEALS

Two Person Family Meal.
12oz of meat + 12oz of two sides + 2pc bread
$
Four Person Family Meal
24oz of meat + 24oz of two sides + 4pc bread
$
Six Person Family Meal
36oz of meat + 36oz of two sides + 6pc bread
$
Eight Person Family Meal
48oz of meat + 48oz of two sides + 8pc bread
$

Snacks

Mini Crab Cake Sliders
fried panko breaded crab balls, citrus dill aioli, iceberg lettuce
$
Fried Buffalo Shrimp
six jumbo shrimp, O.C buffalo sauce, green onions. choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressing
$
X6 Smoked & Fried Wings
bleu cheese or ranch, celery, tossed in choice of sauce: tidewater, stick patches, buffalo, sweet & spicy, bourbon honey mustard, dry rub, naked
US$12.49
X12 Smoked & Fried Wings
bleu cheese or ranch, celery, tossed in choice of sauce: tidewater, stick patches, buffalo, sweet & spicy, bourbon honey mustard, dry rub, naked
US$23.99
Pork Belly Bites
sweet & spicy sauce, virginia peanuts, scallions
US$16.49
Fried Brussels Sprouts
housemade cilantro lime vinaigrette, candied peanuts, cotija cheese
US$11.99
Cheese Fries
smoked cheddar & queso, pickled jalapeno, pickled red onions, scallions
US$15.99
Fried Green Tomatoes
cornmeal breaded green tomatoes, bourbon maple bacon & roasted red onion jam, pimento cheese, sorghum, scallions
US$13.49
Fried VA Oysters
fresno pepper remoulade, pickled fennel & pepper salad, scallions
US$15.99
Pickle Plate
assorted seasonal pickled items
US$11.99
Loaded Mac N' Cheese
garlic queso mac n' cheese w/ your choice of pork, chicken, pork belly, or brisket. topped w/ green onions, OC hot sauce, & sticky patches BBQ.
$
Smoked Pimento Cheese Platter
ritz crackers, shaved Edward's country Ham, O.C. hot sauce, pickles
US$13.99

Soups & Salad

Brunswick Stew
smoked pork & chicken, okra, onions, limas, sweet corn, tomatoes, potatoes, served with cornbread and honey butter
$
Brisket Chili
smoked beef brisket, ground pork, great northern beans, smoked cheddar, crème fraiche, scallions, served with cornbread and honey butter
$
Romaine Salad
pickled red onions, cornbread croutons, cotija cheese, roasted garlic dressing
$
Arugula Salad
apple, pickled fennel, cambazola bleu cheese, candied peanuts, mustard apple cider vinaigrette
$
Add On To Your Salad
$

Sandwiches

Mahi Mahi Sandwich
blackened or fried w/ iceberg lettuce, seasoned tomato, pickled remoulade, brioche potato roll
$
Crab Cake Sandwich
pan seared w/ pickled fresno remoulade, seasoned tomato, iceberg lettuce, & brioche potato roll
$
Oyster Po'Boy
fried VA oysters, pickled fresno remoulade, seasoned tomato, iceberg lettuce, sub roll
$
Shrimp Po'Boy
Fried jumbo shrimp, pickled fresno remoulade, seasoned tomato, iceberg lettuce, sub roll
$
Seared Pork Belly BLT
seared pork belly, heirloom tomatoes, bibb lettuce, basil garlic aioli, toasted sourdough
$
The "Big Hal" Sandwich
A larger than life sandwich, in memoriam, for a larger than life man. sliced brisket, pulled pork, seared pork belly, coleslaw, bread & butter pickles, dill pickles, pickled red onions, soy pickled jalapenos, sticky patches BBQ sauce, brioche potato roll
$
Smoked Brisket Dip
caramelized onions, swiss cheese, horseradish aioli, au jus, baguette
$
Brisket Sandwich
smoked brisket, tobacco onions, soy pickled jalapenos, sticky patches, brioche potato roll
$
Pulled Chicken Sandwich
smoked chicken, coleslaw, brioche potato roll
$
Cubano Sandwich
smoked mojo pork, applewood honey ham, swiss cheese, garlic & dill pickles, roasted garlic dijonnaise, Cuban loaf
$
Buttermilk Fried Chicken Thigh
fried chicken thigh w/ choice of pimento cheese & bread and butter pickles OR buffalo sauce & bleu cheese, brioche potato roll
$
Hot Brown
open faced on sourdough w/ smoked turkey, sage mornay sauce, grilled tomato, bacon, green onion
$
Pulled Pork Sandwich
pulled pork, coleslaw, pickled red onions, brioche potato roll
$
Portobello Sandwich
smoked portobello mushroom, swiss cheese, chimichurri aioli, pickled red onion, arugula, brioche potato roll
$

Tacos

Two Mahi Mahi Tacos
blackened or fried mahi mahi, salsa roja, shredded napa cabbage, diced tomato , green onions. cilantro lime crema or chipotle honey crema
$
Three Mahi Mahi Tacos
blackened or fried mahi mahi, salsa roja, shredded napa cabbage, diced tomato , green onions. cilantro lime crema or chipotle honey crema
$
Two Shrimp Tacos
blackened or fried jumbo shrimp, salsa roja, shredded napa cabbage, diced tomato, green onions. cilantro lime crema or chipotle honey crema
$
Three Shrimp Tacos
blackened or fried jumbo shrimp, salsa roja, shredded napa cabbage, diced tomato , green onions. cilantro lime crema or chipotle honey crema
$
Pork Belly Tacos
Sweet & Spicy sauce, kimchi slaw, cilantro
$
Chopped Smoked Brisket Tacos
coleslaw, pickled jalapenos
$
Green Chili Brisket Tacos
jalapeno cilantro slaw, cotija cheese, creme freche, pickled red onions
$
Pulled Chicken Tacos
jalapeno cilantro slaw, cotija cheese
$
Pulled Pork Tacos
coleslaw, smoked bean puree, bread & butter pickles
$
Taco Sampler
pick three tacos
$

Smoked Meat Platters

2 Meat Platter
selecting double brisket +$3.99 or double ribs +$1.99 per two, three, & four meat platters
$
3 Meat Platter
selecting double brisket +$3.99 or double ribs +$1.99 per two, three, & four meat platters
$
4 Meat Platter
selecting double brisket +$3.99 or double ribs +$1.99 per two, three, & four meat platters
$
Seared Pork Belly Platter
1/2 lb meat served with two sides, pickles
$
Smoked Brisket Platter
1/2 lb meat served with two sides, pickles
$
Pulled Chicken Platter
1/2 lb meat served with two sides, pickles
$
Pulled Pork Platter
1/2 lb meat served with two sides, pickles
$
St. Louis Rib Platter
served with two sides, pickles
$
Smoked Sampler Platter
NO SUBSTITUTIONS ON A SAMPLER PLATTER
$
Pork Belly Bite Platter
1/2 lb of fried pork belly bites, sweet & spicy sauce, virginia peanuts, green onions, choice of two sides.
$

Kids Meals

Kids Brisket Slider
smoked brisket, served w/ one side
$
Kids Pulled Chicken Slider
pulled smoked chicken, served w/ one side
$
Kids Corn Dog Bites
eight corn dog bites, served w/ one side
$
Kids Mac N' Cheese
garlic queso mac n' cheese, served w/ one side
$
Kids Poblano Mac N' Cheese
poblano mac n' cheese, served w/ one side
$
Kids Pulled Pork Slider
pull smoked pork, served w/ one side
$
Kids Buttermilk Fried Chicken Tenders
hand breaded chicken tenders, served w/ one side
$
Kids "Dirt" Dessert
Chocolate Pudding, Oreo Crumble, Gummi Worm
US$3.00
Adult Chicken Tenders
an adult sized portion served w/ one side
$
Adult Corn Dog Bites
$

A La Carte Sides

Applesauce
$
Coleslaw
$
Collard Greens
$
Cornbread W/ Honey Butter
US$2.99
French Fries
$
Side Cheese Fry
$
Side Cheese Fry, Cheese On Side
$
Garlic Queso Mac N' Cheese
$
Jalapeno Coleslaw
$
Poblano Mac N' Cheese
$
Smoked Stout Beans
$
Sweet Potato Fries
$

A La Carte Meats, Pickles, & Sauces

1/4 Lb Seared Pork Belly
US$6.49
1/4 Lb Smoked Brisket
US$10.99
1/4 Lb Pulled Chicken
US$5.99
1/4 Lb Pulled Pork
US$4.99
St. Louis Ribs (Two Bone Section)
US$7.49
Seared Pork Belly By The Pound
US$24.99
Smoked Brisket By The Pound
US$39.99
Pulled Chicken By The Pound
US$19.99
Pulled Pork By The Pound
US$17.99
St. Louis Ribs (Two Bone Sections)
$
Housemade Pickles
$
Pimento Cheese By The Pound
US$14.99
Housemade Sauces By The Pint Or Quart
$

Housemade Desserts

Banana Pudding
caramelized bananas, crumble top
US$9.99
Roasted Peanut Bread Pudding
served w/ whipped cream & bourbon salted caramel
US$9.49
Mrs. Geddy's Chocolate Pie
served w/ whipped cream
US$7.99
Pina Colada Key Lime Pie
whipped cream, pineapple coulis, toasted coconut shavings
US$9.49
Brown Butter Bourbon Pecan Pie
served w/ whipped cream
US$8.49

Extra Add-ons

Add Blackened Shrimp (6ea)
US$9.99
Add Fried Shrimp (6ea)
US$9.99
Add 2oz Bacon Bits
US$1.99
Add 2oz Coleslaw
US$0.50
Add 2oz Pickled Red Onion
US$0.60
Add 2oz Pimento Cheese
US$2.19
Add 2oz Soy Pickled Jalapenos
US$0.75
Add 5.5oz Of House-Made Pickles
US$3.19
Add 5.5oz Queso Cheese Sauce
US$3.49
Add Brioche Potato Roll
US$1.69
Add 2oz House-Made Pickles
US$1.25
Add Slider Bun
US$1.05
Extra 2oz Cheese
US$1.75
Extra 2oz Sour Cream
US$0.75
Extra 2oz Honey Butter
US$0.50
Extra 5oz Pimento Cheese
US$6.49
Extra Ritz Crackers
US$1.99

Extra House Sauce

O.C. Vinegar
US$0.40
Sticky Patches BBQ
US$0.40
Tidewater Mustard
US$0.40
Bleu Cheese Dressing
US$0.40
Ranch Dressing
US$0.40
Bourbon Honey Mustard
US$0.40
Regular Honey Mustard
US$0.40
Sweet & Spicy
US$0.40
O.C. Hot Sauce
US$0.40

Soft Drinks

Club Soda
US$2.75
Coke
US$2.75
Coke Zero
US$2.75
Fanta Orange
US$2.75
Ginger Ale
US$2.75
JUICE
US$2.99
Lemonade
US$2.75
Milk
US$2.75
Mr. Pibb
US$2.75
POWERADE
US$2.75
Root Beer
US$2.75
Shirley Temple
US$2.75
Sprite
US$2.75
Sweet Tea
US$2.75
Tonic Water
US$2.75
Unsweet Tea
US$2.75
Ready to order? Kerbside pickup, delivery and dine-in are all available.